Who Is Your Yes For?
Saying yes has never been easier. A tool will do the work. A partner will fund the idea. A client will pay for the quick version. An audience is waiting for whatever comes next. Very few offers that reach a leader’s desk announce themselves as the wrong one. They arrive looking like progress, and that is why “can we?” has so quietly replaced the harder question of “should we, and who is it for?”
What the Heart Is Already Deciding
Jesus said that
“whatever is in your heart determines what you say” (Matthew 12:34, NLT)
Decisions work the same way. By the time a leader announces a choice, the real decision was made earlier, in a quieter question about what the choice was meant to serve. The mission. The people. The bank balance. The exit. The applause. Most of us would say we are serving the first two. The calendar and the checkbook usually tell the truth about the rest.
The Audience in the Room
A king once made a careless promise at his own birthday dinner. When the request that followed was one he did not want to grant, he granted it anyway,
“because of the vow he had made in front of his guests” (Matthew 14:9, NLT)
He did not want the outcome and he did not believe in it. He simply could not bear to look weak in front of the people watching, and a decision that cost an innocent man his life was made to protect an image.
Few of us will face stakes like those, but the mechanism is ordinary. A date announced publicly before the work was ready. A price promised to a client that quietly lowers the quality. A program kept alive because it has a name and a following. Researchers call this escalation of commitment, a pattern first described by Barry Staw in 1976, in which people keep investing in a chosen course of action despite mounting evidence that it is wrong. More recent experiments with nearly 3,900 participants point to reputation as part of the reason: people who stayed the course were trusted more than people who changed it. Audiences tend to reward consistency, even when consistency is the mistake. So the question to ask before a hard decision is not only what the evidence says. It is who you imagine watching, and what they would think if you changed your mind.
Teams notice this long before leaders do. Every yes given for the sake of an audience teaches the people closest to the work who the real audience is, and they begin to make their own decisions accordingly. The cost shows up slowly, as a team that quietly learns to protect appearances instead of the work.
The Easy Yes Is the Hardest to Spot
I feel this pull in my own work. When you are starting something new, an opportunity that eases the pressure on income can look like an answer when it may only be relief. A partnership that does not quite fit your approach can look like momentum. The test I have learned to use is simple: do I want this because it is right, or because it removes resistance? Those two reasons feel identical in the moment of decision. They produce very different results a year later. One habit helps. When an opportunity arrives with urgency attached, give it one night before you reply. Real opportunities survive a night. Relief rarely does.
A clear purpose matters more than a long list of options. In one short story, a merchant discovers a single pearl of great value and “sold everything he owned” to buy it (Matthew 13:46, NLT). Nobody in the story agonizes over the many things he gave up. When you know exactly what is worth the price, the nos stop being painful and become simple. Steve Jobs described focus as “saying no to the hundred other good ideas.” Notice that he said good ideas. The yes you most need to refuse rarely looks bad.
The Work That Forms You
Tools make the easy yes even easier, because the quickest path is often handing the hard part to something else. That is not always wrong. A tool is excellent at sorting, flagging, and producing a first draft. But some work is more than a deliverable. It is where a leader gets formed. The struggle of writing a message, working through a strategy, or sitting with a hard decision is often where your own judgment takes shape.
A Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon University study of 319 knowledge workers found that people with more confidence in an AI tool applied less critical thinking to its output, while people with more confidence in their own ability engaged more deeply, even though it felt like more effort. Efficiency and wisdom are not the same thing. Peter Drucker once said there is “nothing so useless as doing efficiently that which should not be done at all.”
Before handing something off, ask two questions. Does this make the work better for the people on the receiving end, or only faster for me? And is this the kind of work that is shaping me? Whatever a tool produces, check it before it carries your name.
Conviction You Can Explain
A yes for the right reason should be explainable. Many leaders hold strong convictions but cannot say why they hold them, beyond “it is what we have always done” or “it is what I was taught.” Conviction that has never been tested by disagreement is often borrowed, and borrowed conviction gives way the first time an audience pushes back.
Some of the sharpest thinking I have done came from long conversations with people who saw the world differently than I did, in the middle of a busy restaurant kitchen, where we could disagree, get a little animated, and still say see you tomorrow. Those conversations forced me to put words to what I believed and why. If everyone around you agrees with you, you do not have counsel. You have an echo. The goal is not to win the argument. It is to know your reasons well enough that neither flattery nor pushback can talk you out of them.
Questions Worth Asking Before the Next Yes
Three questions are worth a few quiet minutes. Who is this really for? What will it cost, and who pays that cost if I am wrong? And if no one could ever see that I did it, or that I changed my mind, would I still choose it? The third question is the uncomfortable one, and it is usually the most useful.
None of this asks a leader to turn away every opportunity. It asks for an honest order of operations: decide what the work is for first, then measure each opportunity against that purpose, instead of letting every new offer quietly redefine it. Leaders who do this tend to say yes less often, and to mean it more. Here is a practice for this week. List the open decisions on your desk. Beside each one, write the name of the person or group whose reaction you are most aware of as you consider it. The names are often revealing, and seeing them written down is sometimes enough to change the decision.
Where the Next Right Step Often Starts
It is difficult to hear your own audience from inside a decision. Everyone around you has a stake in the answer, and so do you. A conversation with someone who has no stake in the outcome can bring the real question to the surface. If you are weighing a yes right now, whether in your own business or ministry or on a team that looks to you for direction, the door is open at kingdomplanning.org/book-online, as a one-on-one consultation or as a conversation brought to your leadership group or event. The first conversation is free.
In a first conversation I listen for three things: the decision on the table, the people it will affect, and whose voice is loudest in the room. Sometimes the answer turns out to be a clear yes. Sometimes it is a quiet no. Often it is simply a better question than the one you walked in with.
Whose approval is quietly shaping the next decision on your desk?
Sources: Barry M. Staw, “Knee-Deep in the Big Muddy” (1976); Dorison, Umphres and Lerner, “Staying the Course: Decision Makers Who Escalate Commitment Are Trusted and Trustworthy,” Journal of Experimental Psychology: General; Lee et al., Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon University, CHI 2025; Peter F. Drucker; Steve Jobs.
Stay blessed,





Comments